Season Finale | Cognitive Dissonance

May 16, 2017

A revealing connection is made. A villain emerges. Josh, Jeff, and Sara do some investigating, with varying success. Ellen leaves something behind. An email is sent. A package is shipped. We see the return of several old characters, and meet some new ones. We learn a shocking truth about one of our letter-writers, that changes everything.

Plus, bloopers and drunken ad-libbing, by Jeff and Sara.


Episodes Eleven & Twelve: The Aftershow (w/ Meghan Costella & Ryanne Steele)

May 15, 2017

What starts off as a morose Aftershow (with all that anti-semitism talk) quickly devolves into drunken hysteria when the word of the day comes up 16 times in two consecutive letters. 


Episode Twelve | We Need To Talk About Karen & Ellen

May 9, 2017

Ellen has an awkward dinner with Karen's family. Karen and Rob use a newspaper article to appraise the mermaid clock. The Karen & Ellen Letters hit the stage, and are quickly retired to a box forever. Someone strange enters the fray. 


Episode Eleven | Uh-oh, Scandal

May 2, 2017

A flashback, a 3rd timeline, and a lot of information about the girls' families. Plus, Mark and Ellen become closer; while Mark and Josh hit a snag. 


Episode Ten: The Aftershow (w/ Twisted Philly & In Sight)

April 26, 2017

Deana from the Twisted Philly podcast, and Ali and Charlie from In Sight, join me to discuss Karen and Ellen's strange relationship with Mark, whether socio-economics play a role in stupidity, and Ali's and Charlie's long history with the letters.



Episode Ten | A Sober Dog, or The Curious Case of Justine Sacco

April 25, 2017

Josh piques Karen's interest. A real, old valuable antique goes missing. Ellen writes an OpEd. And new questions about Ellen arise.


Episode Nine | In My Legal Opinion

April 17, 2017

Josh makes several bad decisions after hearing from Karen.
Karen's legal representative weighs in. Karen, Ellen, and Rob need jobs. And the fate of the cat painting is uncovered.


Episode Eight: The Aftershow (w/ Tamie McGranahan, Sue Tortolani)

April 4, 2017

Tamie & Sue (and their pets) return to help unpack this doozy of an episode. We discuss our favorite listener conspiracy theories. Hilarity ensues when 3 secular people try to figure out Ellen's interpretation of Karen's interpretation of Catholocism. And the entire commentary seems to be continually haunted by the spirit of Mary Christ.


Episode Eight | Christmas Tree Farm

April 3, 2017

The train goes off the tracks.


Episode Seven: The Aftershow (w/ Amanda & Lucy from Wine & Crime)

March 28, 2017

This week we instate 2 words of the day, and consequently get very drunk. Amanda has a wine pairing specifically for our protagonists. Ellen outsmarts all of us. And we expound upon a dark theory regarding Ellen’s whereabouts. Plus: A lost letter that didn’t make it into the original episode (because: mistakes were made)!